Or are your ads/commercials losing potential customers, “one cliche at a time?”
If all your agency or someone at your company can come up with for your advertising is a ripoff of an acclaimed ad campaign, like “Got Milk?*” somebody is getting paid too much money for too little thought, and usually, too little results.
Knowing that imitation is the sincerest form of plagiarism, you should eschew it; if you have a hardware store, I (in my role here as the consumer) do not need to see “Got Hammers?” on your employees’ aprons. Hey, I’m already in your store. I know you sell hammers. Tell me something I don’t know, more important, tell me something that would convince me to buy something at your store. How about the aprons saying, “Save energy—yours—with a titanium hammer,” and then have a point of purchase display inform potential buyers that swinging a titanium hammer transfers 97% of your energy from swinging the hammer to the nail head, while a steel hammer transfers only 70% of your energy to the nail. Titanium drives a nail more efficiently and there’s less recoil energy to travel back into your arm.
Finally, think what your attention getting headline is really saying, and whether or not it’s believable (it probably won’t be memorable if every copycat advertiser is already using that phrase or a variation thereof).
Take “One (name it) at a time.” The first use of it made the point of individualized attention, but not every ripoff of that line holds up under scrutiny. One public school system used (briefly) the line, something like “Preparing for the future, one student at a time,” and it just came across as not credible—not with what we hear about overworked teachers, disruptive students, and less than ideal student to teacher ratios. A private school might have been able to use it with more believability. A realtor used something like “Selling real estate, one house at a time.” Really? You must be a part timer or not too successful if you’re currently working on only one sale.
*Got Milk? is an American advertising campaign encouraging the consumption of cow’s milk, which was created by the advertising agency Goodby Silverstein & Partners for the California Milk Processor Board in 1993 and later licensed for use by milk processors and dairy farmers. It has been running since October 29, 1993. The campaign has been credited with greatly increasing milk sales in California, though not nationwide.
The ads would typically feature people in various situations involving dry or sticky foods and treats such as cookies and peanut butter. The person then finds himself in an uncomfortable situation due to a full mouth and no milk to wash it down. At the end of the commercial the character would look sadly to the camera and boldly displayed would be the words, “Got Milk?”.
…The slogan has appeared in numerous alternative versions on t-shirts, advertisements, and real advertisements. For the most part the California Milk Processor Board has ignored the alternative uses, although in 2007 it threatened lawsuit against PETA for its anti-dairy campaign, “Got pus”, which began in 2002. Wikipedia